How we check reviews
Spec Book feedback is about the visit experience — getting an appointment, waiting, reception and staff, being listened to, fees and access. We built it so you can rely on it: practices can't choose, edit or remove what patients say, and we apply the same rules to good and bad feedback.
The numbers, live
Who can leave feedback
- Verified visits. After a visit booked through Spec Book, the patient gets one single-use invitation. Practices can also invite their patients — but only all of them for a day, never a hand-picked few. Feedback from these, and from QR codes inside the rooms, is marked ✓ Verified visit.
- Anyone else who visited can still share their experience from the listing; it shows as “Patient”, without the verified badge.
- One response per listing per person every 30 days. Practice owners, their staff and Spec Book staff can't rate a listing they're connected to.
What we publish — and what stays private
- Scores for each part of the visit, and “would you recommend”, appear straight away and are never hidden because they're low.
- Comments are read by Spec Book before they appear. We publish comments about the visit experience, good or bad, in the patient's own words — we don't rewrite or shorten them.
- Comments about treatment, diagnosis or results are shared privately with the practice instead of being published. Australian law (the National Law's rules on testimonials, section 133) doesn't allow health services to be advertised with clinical testimonials, so Spec Book doesn't publish them for anyone — this keeps every listing on the same footing.
- We remove comments that identify someone, are abusive, are offers or incentives, or come from a conflict of interest.
Integrity checks
- Bursts — an unusual number of responses for one listing in a short time is held for a person to check.
- Copies — the same or near-identical text on more than one response or listing is held.
- Same device — several responses from one browser or connection are held.
- Conflicts — responses from accounts that manage the listing, or a competing listing nearby, are held.
- Held responses aren't counted or shown until staff clear them. Nothing is held just for being negative.
Practices
- Practices can reply publicly, but can't edit, hide, reorder or delete feedback, and can't pay to change it.
- They can flag a comment they believe breaks the rules; Spec Book decides, using the same rules for everyone.
- Patients can update their own feedback later — for example after a practice has fixed a problem — and the update is labelled.
Report a comment
Every published comment has a Report link. Tell us if it isn't a real visit, shares personal information, is offensive, is about treatment, or comes from a conflict of interest. We check every report against these rules — a comment isn't removed just because someone disagrees with it. You can also email support@specbook.com.au.
Feedback describes one person's visit experience. It isn't medical advice or a rating of clinical care — talk to your GP about which practitioner is right for you. In an emergency call 000.